The Guild urges institutions, national and EU policymakers to face up to AI fundamentally redefining what knowledge is, who creates it, who uses it, and how it is applied.
We argue that these epistemic issues are blind spots and elephants in debates that fail to encompass the existential challenge universities face. Unless we address these challenges head on, the paper argues, Europe's universities will not only be left behind globally, but they will also be threatened to the core of their existence.
To address these questions, we propose a framework structured around four dimensions: who knows, who is trusted to validate knowledge, how we know, and what we produce. These dimensions correspond to a set of deep epistemic shifts that require systematic attention: epistemic agency, epistemic authority, epistemic practices and epistemic outputs.
This paper is a call for action to address these epistemic shifts, acknowledging that we do not (yet) have answers to many of the questions. What we need is not a single model or premature consensus, but space to develop, test, challenge and refine diverse approaches. Following the actions addressing schools and AI in the recent Education and skills package, the higher education sector calls for concerted actions at the institutional, national and European levels:
- Universities must encourage and frame debates leading to concrete outcomes. The use of AI must be to enhance the quality of our educational offering and practices, not the quantity. Investment in sustainable pedagogic innovation, including incentives for staff members, must be an integral part of the discussion.
- The EU must support an ambitious and viable European AI infrastructure and provide tools capable of competing with leading global models. Without sustained investment, European higher education will deepen its dependence on external commercial providers. This could be a critical area in which the European Competitiveness Fund and higher education connect.
- The second cycle of the European Education Area (2026-2030) must prioritise the challenge posed by AI because it fundamentally affects Europe’s education, and how we collaborate together. The EEA needs to be informed by the practices of the sector, advising on what works and challenging what does not work.
- National authorities must recognise the epistemic challenges posed by AI, and work with institutions to ensure resources are prioritised to support the systemic transformation. This affects, for instance, funding and incentive models for higher education institutions, expectations/codifications of teaching hours, and funding to incentivise change and ongoing experimentation.
- Quality assurance agencies must recognise that AI challenges all learning outcomes for different levels of courses. National agencies must develop processes for flexibility and responsiveness to changes in AI capabilities, at pace, in close collaboration with universities. How to use AI critically, and in relation to the knowledge generated by it, must become part of learning outcomes in every subject and across disciplines.
